Discover why CardSource.ca offers better terms than Slab Sharks, Savage Cards, Remi Card Trader, and other Canadian consignment services.
Key Takeaways
- CardSource.ca charges 3-5% commission vs 15-20% at many Canadian consignment services.
- Full control — Set your own prices on CardSource.ca vs consignment services that control pricing.
- Instant listing — List cards immediately on CardSource.ca vs waiting weeks for consignment processing.
- Direct sales — Sell directly to buyers on CardSource.ca vs waiting for auction cycles.
- No minimum value — CardSource.ca accepts cards of any value vs $100+ minimums at consignment services.
Fee Comparison: CardSource.ca vs Consignment
Understanding the fee structures helps you make the right choice:
Canadian Consignment Fees
- Slab Sharks: 15-20% commission plus eBay fees
- Savage Cards: 80% payout (20% commission) for sales under $50, 80-95% for higher values
- Remi Card Trader: Commission-based (percentage varies), plus eBay fees
- Nova's Sports Cards: Commission-based, additional fees for eBay/listings
- Krynn: 5% commission on post-tax sale price (Silver tier)
CardSource.ca Fees
- Transaction Fee: 3-5% of sale price
- Listing Fee: $0 — List for free
- Cash-Out Fee: $0 — No withdrawal fees
- No Hidden Fees: No eBay fees, no shipping fees (buyer pays)
Control and Flexibility
The level of control you have over your sales varies significantly:
Consignment Service Limitations
- Pricing Control: Service sets prices or auction starting points
- Auction Format: Most use 7-day auctions, no control over timing
- Listing Control: Cannot adjust prices or descriptions once submitted
- Sale Format: Must accept auction results or service's fixed price
CardSource.ca Advantages
- Pricing Control: Set your own prices, adjust anytime
- Sale Format: Choose fixed price or accept offers
- Listing Control: Edit descriptions, prices, and photos anytime
- Direct Sales: Sell directly to buyers, no auction waiting
Speed and Timeline
How quickly you can sell and get paid matters:
Consignment Service Timeline
- Shipping: Must ship cards to service (1-3 days)
- Processing: 1-2 weeks to receive and catalog
- Listing: 1-2 weeks to list (depending on backlog)
- Auction: 7-day auction cycle
- Payout: 3-5 business days after auction end
- Total: 3-5 weeks from shipping to payout
CardSource.ca Timeline
- Listing: Immediate — list as soon as you upload
- Verification: 1-2 business days
- Live Sale: Cards go live immediately after verification
- Sale: Sell when buyer purchases (no auction wait)
- Payout: 3 business days after sale
- Total: 4-5 days from upload to payout
Canadian Consignment Service Breakdown
Here's a detailed breakdown of major Canadian consignment services:
Slab Sharks
eBay consignment business with weekly 7-day auctions. Competitive rates but requires shipping cards to their location. Payouts within 5 business days after auction end.
Savage Cards
eBay consignment with tiered payout rates (80-95%). Good reputation with nearly 20,000 positive reviews. Requires sleeved and top-loaded cards.
Remi Card Trader
Quebec-based consignment with eBay store (5,000+ positive reviews). Minimum $100 card value. Social media promotion for higher-value cards.
Nova's Sports Cards
Ontario-based consignment for in-store and online sales. Requires completed inventory spreadsheet with pricing. Subject to approval.
Why CardSource.ca is the Better Choice
CardSource.ca offers distinct advantages over Canadian consignment services:
Lower Fees
CardSource.ca charges 3-5% vs 15-20% at most consignment services, saving you money on every sale.
Full Control
Set your own prices, adjust anytime, and choose your sale format. No waiting for auction cycles or service decisions.
Faster Timeline
List immediately and get paid in 4-5 days vs 3-5 weeks with consignment services.
No Minimums
CardSource.ca accepts cards of any value, unlike consignment services that require $100+ minimum values.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is CardSource.ca cheaper than Canadian consignment services?
Yes, CardSource.ca is significantly cheaper. CardSource.ca charges 3-5% transaction fees with no listing or cash-out fees. Canadian consignment services like Slab Sharks and Savage Cards typically charge 15-20% in commission plus additional fees.
Do I have control over pricing on CardSource.ca vs consignment?
Yes, on CardSource.ca you have full control over pricing and can adjust prices anytime. With consignment services, the service typically sets prices or auction starting points, and you have limited control once cards are submitted.
How fast can I sell on CardSource.ca compared to consignment?
CardSource.ca allows immediate listing and sales can happen within 4-5 days from upload to payout. Consignment services typically take 3-5 weeks from shipping to payout due to processing, listing, and auction cycles.
Does CardSource.ca have minimum card values like consignment services?
No, CardSource.ca accepts cards of any value. Many Canadian consignment services have minimum card values of $100 or more, rejecting lower-value cards.
What fees does CardSource.ca charge compared to Slab Sharks?
CardSource.ca charges 3-5% transaction fees with no additional fees. Slab Sharks charges 15-20% commission plus eBay fees, making CardSource.ca significantly more cost-effective.
Why should I choose CardSource.ca over Canadian consignment?
Choose CardSource.ca for lower fees (3-5% vs 15-20%), faster payouts (4-5 days vs 3-5 weeks), full pricing control, no minimum card values, and the ability to sell directly to buyers without waiting for auction cycles.
